I told you that would be my post-edits announcement. It took over 37,000 words, several incredibly helpful friends, one month and one day and a lot of stress, but I got Wingspan into the 5-figure range. I promised myself I'd do it before I left for my well-earned vacation to California and that meant that while I finished the edit on the 20th, I finished the formatting at the SLC airport on the 21st and sent the e-mail to the mysterious E. from Gate E-80, where I was waiting for the flight from Utah to San Jose.
But whatever! I did it! The hardest part of the whole process was getting to the last page of the book and discovering that I still had 6656 words left. Then I turned back to page 1 and had 15 words per page that I had to cut instead of 68. When I was cutting 65 per page, I felt immensely powerful. Later on, it was more in the range of 35 words per page until it trickled down to a handful per page by the end.
So, now that I'm back from 5 days in the Bay Area (sort of), I thought I'd post my happiness and also give a few Easter eggs.
EE1: The tarot reader is named Marianne, in honor of the friend who not only did my first reading but gave me my own tarot deck a couple of years ago.
EE2: Avril is a variation on an old roommate and channels her occasionally.
EE3: Sosi is based on an Armenian-American friend from choir and would have been named Vana if I didn't want to go with something different.
EE4: The therapist is named for one of my nephews. It doesn'r use the last name, but the rest is the same.
EE5: At one point, the Byrne family goes to an unnamed restaurant in Wayland for a special occasion. This is an Easter egg because the restaurant it's meant to be (Which is sadly closed now) is called Hillary's. If you know me in real life, you'll understand who that's honoring. It's also where my family went for special occasions as well.
EE6: The therapist is named for a nephew by my younger sister. The Byrne sisters' favorite aunt has a name that's just one letter away from matching hers.
EE7: All of the girls on the JV soccer team are named for people I disliked in my hometown, especially the idiot named Mari.
Tuesday, May 26, 2015
Tuesday, April 21, 2015
Climb Every Mountain
No, this isn't a Kevin J. Anderson-style hiking post. This is a story...well, actually two stories. These are two stories about my week so far.
As I mentioned before, I submitted my manuscript on Saturday. On Monday, during a brief break, I got an e-mail saying "Oh, I needed to mention that this needs to be no longer than 100,000." I promptly had a panic attack, had to take a walk around the office under the convenient pretense of filing (my boss needed me to do it anyway) and then came back. 100,000 requires me to cut at least 37,000 words from my manuscript.
So, here are the two stories. The first one was from when I was a wee lass of seven. I had the chicken pox quite badly and was out of school for a while. During that time, I had lots of hours on my hands, so I finished this huge project to write all of the numbers from 1-1000 in order. I was so proud of myself. This was not only an important homework assignment, but members of the 1000 Club got their names in the school newspaper. I turned it in to Mrs. Bartman, my teacher and she looked it over before announcing that I had skipped 367 and had to write 368-1000 all over again.
The second one is from when I was a little less wee. My parents, who celebrated their 40th anniversary last Friday, decided to take whichever kids were available on a backpacking trip to Peru for their 25th anniversary. I trained for months. I lost weight. I drank mate de coca like shots in the lobby of our hotel because that helps get lowlanders used to the Andes. On Day 3 of our 5-day hike to Macchu Pichu, we got to Dead Woman's Pass. Williams, our guide, warned us that it was the most difficult part of the hike and he was right. This was a punishing part of the Inca Trail. It punished me for being fat, for being a hiker, for being easily sunburned, for existing. (This is also, it turns out, when I started developing what became a 103-degree fever.) The trail narrowed from its usual 5-10 feet or more to about 2. at some points. The stones were loose. There was a drop so steep that all I could see were the tops of the trees hundreds of feet below. I literally got on my hands and knees for part of this trail in order to make it to the top. A couple of hours later, I reached the peak. Williams greeted me, gave me a high five, and promised me that I was almost to the spot where we were stopping for lunch. I grinned and told him to lead the way. He pointed across a narrow valley and halfway up the next mountain and said, "THERE! See that little yellow tent? That's where we're setting up lunch." I came THIS CLOSE to pushing him down Dead Woman's Pass right then and there.
I don't feel quite that strongly about these 37,000 words. After all, they're only 68 words per page. I can do that. But I feel like I did looking at that distant yellow tent--exhausted and like I just want to sit down for a while and ignore how far I have to go. I feel like I did at the age of 7 when I found out that for all my work, I had to back and work hard again.
It is for that reason that I will post at the end of this draft what I have on my t-shirt from that hike: I SURVIVED DEAD WOMAN'S PASS!
As I mentioned before, I submitted my manuscript on Saturday. On Monday, during a brief break, I got an e-mail saying "Oh, I needed to mention that this needs to be no longer than 100,000." I promptly had a panic attack, had to take a walk around the office under the convenient pretense of filing (my boss needed me to do it anyway) and then came back. 100,000 requires me to cut at least 37,000 words from my manuscript.
So, here are the two stories. The first one was from when I was a wee lass of seven. I had the chicken pox quite badly and was out of school for a while. During that time, I had lots of hours on my hands, so I finished this huge project to write all of the numbers from 1-1000 in order. I was so proud of myself. This was not only an important homework assignment, but members of the 1000 Club got their names in the school newspaper. I turned it in to Mrs. Bartman, my teacher and she looked it over before announcing that I had skipped 367 and had to write 368-1000 all over again.
The second one is from when I was a little less wee. My parents, who celebrated their 40th anniversary last Friday, decided to take whichever kids were available on a backpacking trip to Peru for their 25th anniversary. I trained for months. I lost weight. I drank mate de coca like shots in the lobby of our hotel because that helps get lowlanders used to the Andes. On Day 3 of our 5-day hike to Macchu Pichu, we got to Dead Woman's Pass. Williams, our guide, warned us that it was the most difficult part of the hike and he was right. This was a punishing part of the Inca Trail. It punished me for being fat, for being a hiker, for being easily sunburned, for existing. (This is also, it turns out, when I started developing what became a 103-degree fever.) The trail narrowed from its usual 5-10 feet or more to about 2. at some points. The stones were loose. There was a drop so steep that all I could see were the tops of the trees hundreds of feet below. I literally got on my hands and knees for part of this trail in order to make it to the top. A couple of hours later, I reached the peak. Williams greeted me, gave me a high five, and promised me that I was almost to the spot where we were stopping for lunch. I grinned and told him to lead the way. He pointed across a narrow valley and halfway up the next mountain and said, "THERE! See that little yellow tent? That's where we're setting up lunch." I came THIS CLOSE to pushing him down Dead Woman's Pass right then and there.
I don't feel quite that strongly about these 37,000 words. After all, they're only 68 words per page. I can do that. But I feel like I did looking at that distant yellow tent--exhausted and like I just want to sit down for a while and ignore how far I have to go. I feel like I did at the age of 7 when I found out that for all my work, I had to back and work hard again.
It is for that reason that I will post at the end of this draft what I have on my t-shirt from that hike: I SURVIVED DEAD WOMAN'S PASS!
Saturday, April 18, 2015
Lessons learned from this round of edits
So, at 11:22 a.m. MDT, I hit the send button on my e-mail back to that extremely kind editor that I mentioned recently. I have been working on putting her ideas into their place for 39 days and now what's left is to wait to see what she thinks about how I implemented them.
So, while waiting, here are a few lessons learned:
1) My friends are awesome. They texted and called me, sometimes at 4 in the morning, to see how I was doing and if I needed anything. They sent me pictures of badgers when I needed to be badgered. They even sent me a stuffed badger and helped me name her Susurrus. They kept track of when my deadline was and liked my Facebook posts a lot by way of encouragement.
2) My friends can be counted on for brainstorms. I'm not sure if I told this story here, but one of the things I had to explore in this round of edits was the limit of the curse and what would allow the curse to win. I first figured out that it had to be something to do with adulthood, because that is a point that differs so widely that the age of majority is nothing but a number. Then I refined it to a specific moment in life and worked out the why of that technicality. Then I picked on my two most extreme feminists. One is my amazingly strong lesbian friend who always keeps me informed on the LGBTQ community's rights and issues. One is my fantastically intelligent mom of 2 friend who has something to say about EVERYTHING related to women. I figured that if I could get both of them to not hate that idea, I would be fine. I had six people of various sexualities and backgrounds give me feedback in the end and they all loved it for different reasons.
3) My roommate is a never-ending fount of editing power. I wouldn't let her actually read this final draft because she just finished meeting one of my deadlines and has already edited the book and put up with my "Hey, could you give me feedback on something"s. That doesn't mean that she didn't sit down with me for an hour the first night and several occasions since to hash out the details. I have promised her that unless this manuscript comes back with really unfavorable responses, the next time I want her to read my book is for a blog tour.
4) That stupid quote about the best-laid plans of mice and men is true. I thought giving myself 40 days was so freaking reasonable. E, the mystery editor, told me it could take between 2 weeks and a couple of months. And then I woke up 11 days into editing with bronchitis and it didn't leave for two weeks. Granted, that's when I spent all of my time getting feedback from a wide spectrum of women, but I would have rather been well and able to write.
5) Goals are my friend. I would ask a random friend to give me a number each day and make that my wordcount goal. I wrote 520 and 1266 and such things and then usually had energy left over to write more.
6) I need a nap. No, seriously, I think I'll be able to sleep properly for the first time in weeks tonight.
So, while waiting, here are a few lessons learned:
1) My friends are awesome. They texted and called me, sometimes at 4 in the morning, to see how I was doing and if I needed anything. They sent me pictures of badgers when I needed to be badgered. They even sent me a stuffed badger and helped me name her Susurrus. They kept track of when my deadline was and liked my Facebook posts a lot by way of encouragement.
2) My friends can be counted on for brainstorms. I'm not sure if I told this story here, but one of the things I had to explore in this round of edits was the limit of the curse and what would allow the curse to win. I first figured out that it had to be something to do with adulthood, because that is a point that differs so widely that the age of majority is nothing but a number. Then I refined it to a specific moment in life and worked out the why of that technicality. Then I picked on my two most extreme feminists. One is my amazingly strong lesbian friend who always keeps me informed on the LGBTQ community's rights and issues. One is my fantastically intelligent mom of 2 friend who has something to say about EVERYTHING related to women. I figured that if I could get both of them to not hate that idea, I would be fine. I had six people of various sexualities and backgrounds give me feedback in the end and they all loved it for different reasons.
3) My roommate is a never-ending fount of editing power. I wouldn't let her actually read this final draft because she just finished meeting one of my deadlines and has already edited the book and put up with my "Hey, could you give me feedback on something"s. That doesn't mean that she didn't sit down with me for an hour the first night and several occasions since to hash out the details. I have promised her that unless this manuscript comes back with really unfavorable responses, the next time I want her to read my book is for a blog tour.
4) That stupid quote about the best-laid plans of mice and men is true. I thought giving myself 40 days was so freaking reasonable. E, the mystery editor, told me it could take between 2 weeks and a couple of months. And then I woke up 11 days into editing with bronchitis and it didn't leave for two weeks. Granted, that's when I spent all of my time getting feedback from a wide spectrum of women, but I would have rather been well and able to write.
5) Goals are my friend. I would ask a random friend to give me a number each day and make that my wordcount goal. I wrote 520 and 1266 and such things and then usually had energy left over to write more.
6) I need a nap. No, seriously, I think I'll be able to sleep properly for the first time in weeks tonight.
Sunday, April 5, 2015
The Importance of Self-Fanfic
So to go into a little more detail than I have in the past, I got a bite rather than a nibble from one publisher. I got a very nice e-mail where one of their editors told me all of the things she liked about and that she had some "general edits" that she wanted me to address before she recommended it for publication. This is the most serious interest that I've had in my writing EVER, which is why when I saw an e-mail entitled "Re: Wingspan Submission," I literally blacked out for an unknown period of time. Then I read the letter and it wasn't a rejection and was better than I expected.
So, with these "general edits," I've had to go back and tweak a few minor things and one or two major things. On the day that I got the e-mail, Kate let me pick her brain for an hour. The following Sunday, I spent a little more time than that talking about the philosophies behind what I had to change. Tonight, I spent time consulting a paralegal and a nursing student in order to be accurate with certain aspects of the plot. Last weekend, I cane up with a much more intricateversion of the curse and because it expressed some very personal philosophies of mine, I ran it by my ultra-feminist conservative Mormon friend, my lesbian activist friend and several people across the spectrum in between. When all of them surprisingly found good things to say about what I came up with, I called it a win and decided that I could integrate that idea into the book series as large.
Most of the time, the edits have not been sweeping story arcs and changes of characterization. It's been adapting small things that will have eventual significance. One minor subplot caused Kate to have a crossover idea between this book and The Deserter, which amused and delighted me.
As difficult as this is, I think it would be a lot harder if I hadn't been keeping an active part of my brain involved in this universe. For a writing challenge a few months ago, I wrote a missing moment from the next book. I recently cheered Kate up by writing her the prologue of the next book. While the manuscript was done a while back, I haven't put it on a back burner. I've been acting like a fangirl with my novel and that has been of great help.
On the other hand, I'm trying to work with a self-imposed deadline for these edits to be done. 40 days seemed reasonable on March 10. On March 21, when I was starting to make progress, I developed bronchitis and didn't stay conscious for much of the next week and a half. Now I've got 14 days before I'd like to be done with this and, while I have over 8,000 words added to the manuscript and have the rest of the procedure mapped out, I'm trying not to panic about how much time has passed already.
So, with these "general edits," I've had to go back and tweak a few minor things and one or two major things. On the day that I got the e-mail, Kate let me pick her brain for an hour. The following Sunday, I spent a little more time than that talking about the philosophies behind what I had to change. Tonight, I spent time consulting a paralegal and a nursing student in order to be accurate with certain aspects of the plot. Last weekend, I cane up with a much more intricateversion of the curse and because it expressed some very personal philosophies of mine, I ran it by my ultra-feminist conservative Mormon friend, my lesbian activist friend and several people across the spectrum in between. When all of them surprisingly found good things to say about what I came up with, I called it a win and decided that I could integrate that idea into the book series as large.
Most of the time, the edits have not been sweeping story arcs and changes of characterization. It's been adapting small things that will have eventual significance. One minor subplot caused Kate to have a crossover idea between this book and The Deserter, which amused and delighted me.
As difficult as this is, I think it would be a lot harder if I hadn't been keeping an active part of my brain involved in this universe. For a writing challenge a few months ago, I wrote a missing moment from the next book. I recently cheered Kate up by writing her the prologue of the next book. While the manuscript was done a while back, I haven't put it on a back burner. I've been acting like a fangirl with my novel and that has been of great help.
On the other hand, I'm trying to work with a self-imposed deadline for these edits to be done. 40 days seemed reasonable on March 10. On March 21, when I was starting to make progress, I developed bronchitis and didn't stay conscious for much of the next week and a half. Now I've got 14 days before I'd like to be done with this and, while I have over 8,000 words added to the manuscript and have the rest of the procedure mapped out, I'm trying not to panic about how much time has passed already.
Saturday, March 21, 2015
Tangential delights--Review of Lauren Skidmore's "What Is Lost."
You know, one of the worst things that I can say at the end of a book is "I didn't see that coming." I remember co-reading Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (Kate and I were on opposite ends of the living room, reading from midnight until 7:50 a.m.) and being slightly exasperated by her frequent jaunts to her bedroom. She would be checking a reference or revelation against a previous installment of the series. One of the best "reveals" was when we witnessed a young Severus Snape telling Lily Evans about dementors and finally understood that Petunia's comment about hearing about dementors from "That awful boy" was not a slight against James Potter.
I love a mystery as much as the next person, but I love a mystery with antecedents. When it gets to the denoument, I expect to be nodding and smiling at the cool logic and clear presentation.
All of that goes to say that, yes, I quite enjoyed the second book in Lauren's series. I developed a theory about the ending about 50 pages in and spent the rest of the time finding things to back up my theory or to throw me for a loop. When it came to the climax and I found myself nodding and smiling and saying, "Of course! That makes sense!", it was with fondness. So my first recommendation is that this is a great mystery with an indeterminate audience.
Let me take a moment to talk about the characters. While I half-expected to see the story of the first book continued, having it told from the point of the antagonist was a master stroke. It made me question everything that we knew about him from the first book. I was never quite sure if I liked him--he was a man with good intentions and a really screwy way of working with them--but I never thought of him as an unrealistic character.
For its subtitle, the Little Red Riding Hood story didn't play as much of a part as I anticipated. I loved that the Gradmother is a bit of a criminal mastermind and the Wolf reminded me of Ras Al-Ghul at times. As someone who knows of Lauren's fixation with Japan, I enjoyed seeing this second book set in the culture and some of the customs of that country. It amused me that every person of consequence in the book seemed to have ninja training, but that again can be attributed to either the Japanese influence or the Ras Al-Ghul factor.
As I recently said to Kate, the highest compliment I can pay this book is "There HAS to be a sequel." If the story is left there, I will feel cheated and a little bit resentful. So, until that comes out, please join me in becoming fans of the series.
Where to find this:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1462116213/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeASIN=1462116213&linkCode=as2&tag=laureskidm-20&linkId=YVGN5CCCKE2K6TNU
http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/what-is-lost-lauren-skidmore/1120112503?ean=9781462116218
Monday, March 16, 2015
Build-up Binder--An Exercise in Self-Therapy
So, you'll be getting another post soon. If you remember Lauren Skidmore's wonderful book--What is Hidden--I get to blog-tour the sequel this Sunday. Stay tuned!
In the mean time, I'll talk about the power of positive thinking. This isn't something that comes easily to me. I'm a Bostonian and someone with clinical depression and PTSD. This often means that I want to punch people in the face when they try to hug out a problem. I stayed away from a well-meant church activity where someone lectured on happiness.
Counseling and medication could undoubtedly help with this, but right now, I work 40 hours a week take piano lessons, play for choir, teach Sunday School, have season tickets to the Symphony, am training for a 10K... I have yet to find time since moving to my new town to actually find a therapist, a psychiatrist or a reliable GP who doesn't tell me that if a migraine lasts more than four hours, it's no longer a migraine but a cry for attention.
So, what do I do instead? To be honest, I bang on the piano a lot. I run my butt off at the local gym. I eat too much Mexican food.
Recently, I got a response to Wingspan that I'll talk about more later. The person greeted me like a friend, called the writing witty and lovely and at one point called the idea genius. Yes, I've gotten this sort of thing said about fanfic before, but she went into so much detail that I had a hard time not crying because she went into such detail about the characters and plot and intentions that,,,
Well, let me put it this way. Kate has been contributing ideas and feedback to Wingspan for so long that I feel like Aislin and Maeve are in on our circle of friends. We have in jokes with them. We care about what's going on in their lives. This person, who recently read this unpublished book, made me feel like she's a genuine friend to my characters as well.
What this has to do with my depression is this: I went to Wal-Mart and got a green binder. I'm going to print off things that people have written to me that make me feel good about myself and put them in that binder. In there will be the e-mail from this friend of the series as well as the page where Kate wrote "THIS IS BRILLIANT!" about the Kafka reference three-quarters of the way through the book. It will include my favorite reviews on fanfics, from the "OH MY GOD!" variations to the ones from my Irish barrister friend. It will even include funny tweets I've gotten in response to my own tweets.
In the mean time, I'll talk about the power of positive thinking. This isn't something that comes easily to me. I'm a Bostonian and someone with clinical depression and PTSD. This often means that I want to punch people in the face when they try to hug out a problem. I stayed away from a well-meant church activity where someone lectured on happiness.
Counseling and medication could undoubtedly help with this, but right now, I work 40 hours a week take piano lessons, play for choir, teach Sunday School, have season tickets to the Symphony, am training for a 10K... I have yet to find time since moving to my new town to actually find a therapist, a psychiatrist or a reliable GP who doesn't tell me that if a migraine lasts more than four hours, it's no longer a migraine but a cry for attention.
So, what do I do instead? To be honest, I bang on the piano a lot. I run my butt off at the local gym. I eat too much Mexican food.
Recently, I got a response to Wingspan that I'll talk about more later. The person greeted me like a friend, called the writing witty and lovely and at one point called the idea genius. Yes, I've gotten this sort of thing said about fanfic before, but she went into so much detail that I had a hard time not crying because she went into such detail about the characters and plot and intentions that,,,
Well, let me put it this way. Kate has been contributing ideas and feedback to Wingspan for so long that I feel like Aislin and Maeve are in on our circle of friends. We have in jokes with them. We care about what's going on in their lives. This person, who recently read this unpublished book, made me feel like she's a genuine friend to my characters as well.
What this has to do with my depression is this: I went to Wal-Mart and got a green binder. I'm going to print off things that people have written to me that make me feel good about myself and put them in that binder. In there will be the e-mail from this friend of the series as well as the page where Kate wrote "THIS IS BRILLIANT!" about the Kafka reference three-quarters of the way through the book. It will include my favorite reviews on fanfics, from the "OH MY GOD!" variations to the ones from my Irish barrister friend. It will even include funny tweets I've gotten in response to my own tweets.
Saturday, February 7, 2015
Did You Mean To Do That?--My reasons for not self-publishing
So, on a regular basis, when people find out that not only do I want to be a novelist, but have already written two books, they follow up the questions about queries and submissions with this: "And you're not going to self-publish?"
My usual response is a very quick one: "I don't have the self-confidence for that!" I laugh at myself and my neurotic tendencies and go back to letting them know which people or places are considering my work.
Today, I thought I would give a slightly longer explanation. Let's be clear: This is not a condemnation of the people who decide to self-publish. It's my perspective of how my brain works and how that affects my aspirations.
To illustrate most simply, let's visit another one of my hobbies. I play six instruments, but the one that I'm studying most actively right now is piano. A couple of years ago, I realized that my teacher was essentially being paid to sit behind me and tell me "That's making real improvement" and occasionally, "Do you think that you should work more on the fluidity of your sixteenth notes?" She was good at helping me construct a program and had some helpful tips, but she wasn't helping me make real progress as much as I liked. I decided that it was time for us to part ways and, in the middle of this process, I told my mother that I was looking for a teacher who would get my music moving forward again. Since Mom has a master's degree in piano pedagogy and an active piano studio, she offered to take over.
My mother is a lovely woman, but she's a tough teacher. She doesn't let me get away with comfortable fingering that doesn't quite work. She makes me do scales and Hanon exercises. She recently made me play the same ten-note run for about four minutes because I kept having a fluidity problem in the middle and we were working out where my hand was tripping itself up.
One of our favorite refrains is "Did you mean to do that?" The story behind this is that my mother went in for a first piano lesson with a renowned pianist and pedagogue. After a few measures of her first piece, the woman mildly said, "Did you mean to do that? I thought not." It's a phrase that no one wants to hear, whether after three measures of a Bach two-part invention or three pages into a Beethoven sonata.
The result of this style of teaching is that my music is definitely moving forward. I spend more time thinking about my fingering, working on the exact mechanics of how my hand gets through a tough spot. I find myself thinking constantly, "Did you mean to do that? I thought not." This is the sort of process that works for me. It is a rejection-heavy way of approaching a goal, but it's the way I learned to get results.
I played many auditions growing up. One of my worst experiences was when I had to play a seating audition for my senior year in New England Conservatory's Youth Repertory Orchestra. I had been playing under Melba Sandberg in the orchestra for a year at this point and thought I was pretty good. Before I even played a note, Melba turned to the conductor who was helping her with the evaluations and said, "This is Kathryn Olsen, one of my violists. You can never tell what you're going to get with her. She can be flawless or hopeless." I was utterly humiliated by the comment and don't even remember if I played flawlessly or hopelessly at that audition. I can tell you that junior year, I was twelfth chair and senior year, I was sixth and that at least tells me that I was good. Maybe even very good. Melba thought there were twelve violists who played worse than me that day.
These sorts of experiences translate into how I perceive my writing. I've shared my writing with others for 22 years now, since I started posting fanfic on fanfix.com. I've had rave reviews. I've had people post replies no more coherent than "OH MY GOD. OH...MY...GOD! GOD! OH...GOD! OH, MY GOD!" I've had people write me essays on my characterization. Needless to say, my readers often make me feel very good. They are essentially the piano teacher sitting back and telling me, "That's making real improvement." They are also like the marvelously supportive friends who show up for my piano recitals and clap like mad when I finish anything.
What I need are more of the Moms and Melbas. My best times while writing these days are when I sit down to write with the three friends who co-write the Botosphere with me. They know where things are working, ask me for clarification, say "No, just no" on occasion and burst out in hysterical laughter at other times. Some paragraphs come out easily. Some less so. My favorite parts are where one writer will start a sentence and write "[Insert something witty by Ish here.]"
My best critic is, of course, Katey. She reads with a conusmer's eye and an editor's brain. At one point in Wingspan, she wrote "THIS IS BRILLIANT" at the top of a page and underscored it twice. I swear, I'm never deleting the pic that I have of that because I know how high praise that was from her.
So, what am I looking for with publishing? I could self-publish and have the pleasure of seeing reviews pop up on Amazon and seeing my Kindle sales. That would give me a really good feeling, the kind that I get when I get reviews on my posts at fanfiction.net. But what would make me happiest is someone whose job it was to dislike most of what they read genuinely liked it. It would feel just a little bit like getting sixth chair from the person who called me either flawless or hopeless.
My usual response is a very quick one: "I don't have the self-confidence for that!" I laugh at myself and my neurotic tendencies and go back to letting them know which people or places are considering my work.
Today, I thought I would give a slightly longer explanation. Let's be clear: This is not a condemnation of the people who decide to self-publish. It's my perspective of how my brain works and how that affects my aspirations.
To illustrate most simply, let's visit another one of my hobbies. I play six instruments, but the one that I'm studying most actively right now is piano. A couple of years ago, I realized that my teacher was essentially being paid to sit behind me and tell me "That's making real improvement" and occasionally, "Do you think that you should work more on the fluidity of your sixteenth notes?" She was good at helping me construct a program and had some helpful tips, but she wasn't helping me make real progress as much as I liked. I decided that it was time for us to part ways and, in the middle of this process, I told my mother that I was looking for a teacher who would get my music moving forward again. Since Mom has a master's degree in piano pedagogy and an active piano studio, she offered to take over.
My mother is a lovely woman, but she's a tough teacher. She doesn't let me get away with comfortable fingering that doesn't quite work. She makes me do scales and Hanon exercises. She recently made me play the same ten-note run for about four minutes because I kept having a fluidity problem in the middle and we were working out where my hand was tripping itself up.
One of our favorite refrains is "Did you mean to do that?" The story behind this is that my mother went in for a first piano lesson with a renowned pianist and pedagogue. After a few measures of her first piece, the woman mildly said, "Did you mean to do that? I thought not." It's a phrase that no one wants to hear, whether after three measures of a Bach two-part invention or three pages into a Beethoven sonata.
The result of this style of teaching is that my music is definitely moving forward. I spend more time thinking about my fingering, working on the exact mechanics of how my hand gets through a tough spot. I find myself thinking constantly, "Did you mean to do that? I thought not." This is the sort of process that works for me. It is a rejection-heavy way of approaching a goal, but it's the way I learned to get results.
I played many auditions growing up. One of my worst experiences was when I had to play a seating audition for my senior year in New England Conservatory's Youth Repertory Orchestra. I had been playing under Melba Sandberg in the orchestra for a year at this point and thought I was pretty good. Before I even played a note, Melba turned to the conductor who was helping her with the evaluations and said, "This is Kathryn Olsen, one of my violists. You can never tell what you're going to get with her. She can be flawless or hopeless." I was utterly humiliated by the comment and don't even remember if I played flawlessly or hopelessly at that audition. I can tell you that junior year, I was twelfth chair and senior year, I was sixth and that at least tells me that I was good. Maybe even very good. Melba thought there were twelve violists who played worse than me that day.
These sorts of experiences translate into how I perceive my writing. I've shared my writing with others for 22 years now, since I started posting fanfic on fanfix.com. I've had rave reviews. I've had people post replies no more coherent than "OH MY GOD. OH...MY...GOD! GOD! OH...GOD! OH, MY GOD!" I've had people write me essays on my characterization. Needless to say, my readers often make me feel very good. They are essentially the piano teacher sitting back and telling me, "That's making real improvement." They are also like the marvelously supportive friends who show up for my piano recitals and clap like mad when I finish anything.
What I need are more of the Moms and Melbas. My best times while writing these days are when I sit down to write with the three friends who co-write the Botosphere with me. They know where things are working, ask me for clarification, say "No, just no" on occasion and burst out in hysterical laughter at other times. Some paragraphs come out easily. Some less so. My favorite parts are where one writer will start a sentence and write "[Insert something witty by Ish here.]"
My best critic is, of course, Katey. She reads with a conusmer's eye and an editor's brain. At one point in Wingspan, she wrote "THIS IS BRILLIANT" at the top of a page and underscored it twice. I swear, I'm never deleting the pic that I have of that because I know how high praise that was from her.
So, what am I looking for with publishing? I could self-publish and have the pleasure of seeing reviews pop up on Amazon and seeing my Kindle sales. That would give me a really good feeling, the kind that I get when I get reviews on my posts at fanfiction.net. But what would make me happiest is someone whose job it was to dislike most of what they read genuinely liked it. It would feel just a little bit like getting sixth chair from the person who called me either flawless or hopeless.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
